Batman has been a popular character of American culture since his arrival in Detective Comics #27, issued in 1939. Since then, Batman and the world of Gotham have been reborn time and time again. In the 1992 cartoon Batman: The Animated Series, the Bat takes on an ensemble of villains that run the organized crime that plagues Gotham, while in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight of 2008, the caped crusader squares off against the Joker, a self-described "agent of chaos," who threatens the order of Gotham with fear itself. Both of these adaptations are among the most iconic renditions ever of Batman on the screen.
Character
1992: The definitive dichotomy of brooding Batman and suave playboy millionaire Bruce Wayne isn't strayed away from in the animated series. Compared to Christian Bale's Batman/Bruce Wayne, Kevin Conroy's character fits more into the noir-investigator role. The Animated Batman is much more likely to shoot off wisecracks when fighting bad guys and the Animated Bruce Wayne is depicted as a cunning and active, if arrogant, business philanthropist. The Animated Series also features Batman using the Bruce Wayne alter ego quite heavily in his investigations compared to Nolan's Batman.
2008: As already stated, Christian Bale's character still follows the dichotomy of Batman/Bruce Wayne, but Bale's Batman leans more into the brooding than Conroy's. The Bruce Wayne of Nolan's Gotham is also depicted as more of a shallow, hedonistic, absent-minded silver spoon heir, who serves mostly as a mask for Batman rather than a tool to be used in investigations.
Genre
1992: As an action-adventure kids cartoon, the animated show is far less violent than the 2008 movie and features more lighthearted moments. However, the series is still dark and complex, earning it critical acclaim. The show also leans more into pulp noir themes than the movie.
2008: Christopher Nolan's movie is more visceral and violent than the animated show, as well as featuring some incredibly intense moments. The movie fits into the categories of drama and thriller as much as a superhero and action.
Ideology
1992: In most episodes, you get to watch Batman clean Gotham's streets of organized crime and lock up the villain in Arkham Asylum. Often, the villain is someone that can be sympathized with, and Batman usually offers chances of redemption. But when it's refused, to Arkham Asylum they go, as that's the way to criminals should be handled. Villain's plots are usually centered around powerful weapons, "power-up" substances, or doomsday plots that terrorize the city. These are related to things such as weaponized violence in organized crime, the drug epidemics of the 1980s, and the rise of terrorism.
2008: The plot of the movie centers around the growing mistrust of Batman's effectiveness and legality, which Bruce believes is a sign that Harvey Dent must take on the role of Gotham's protector, as well as the Joker's reign of terror over the city. Joker's influence over the city, causing chaos and panic throughout the city, plays on the influence of media on American perceptions of things like terrorism, protesting, and the recession. Batman's methods of combatting Joker, primarily the High-Frequency Resonator device, is commentary on how the government should take on said issues.
Social History
1992: Mob culture has been a staple in American media, but particular fascination arose in the 90s as RICO laws cracked down on the organizations hard, starting in the 80s. With numerous mobsters testifying and informing both government and the general public, American media sunk its teeth into the Mafia. Out of this decade came a golden age of mobster media, such as Goodfellas, Pulp Fiction, Casino, and near the end of the decade, The Sopranos, just to name a few. And nowhere was more iconic of American gangsters than New York City, of which Gotham was inspired. Related to organized crime was the drug epidemic of the 80s that had no end in sight. Therefore, Batman's enemies often resemble the organizations of gangsters, if not being the mob itself.
2008: The Great Recession of 2008 defines the year for America, as well as the rising racial tensions, the war on terror, and the rise of social media (and the subsequent commodification of data) that persisted throughout the decade. It was a time of change, uncertainty, and fear, with America's first black President leading the country through the storm. The High-Frequency Resonator, a device that allows Batman to monitor every single cellular device in Gotham to catch the Joker, which is subsequently destroyed after its use by Lucius Fox, is a reference to the PATRIOT Act and the danger it poses to the American people.
Semiotics
Syntagmatic: Both the Animated Series and the 2008 film feature the best Clown Princes ever put on screen (this is NOT up for debate), but the two Jokers are quite different from each other. Mark Hamil's Joker in the cartoon leans more into the twisted sense of humor, with some outright hilariously silly bits that occur in the show. Heath Ledger's jaw-dropping performance is far more sinister and gritty; while there are still funny moments, the Joker of The Dark Knight is terrifyingly dark, toying with and actively challenging Batman. Both Jokers are perfect foils to Batman, but their roles in their respective relationships are different. The animated Joker is ultimately another criminal wanting profit that Batman needs to thwart, while Ledger's Joker is an "agent of chaos" who isn't in it for the money, but wants Batman to see Gotham descend into chaos. In the animated series, it's Batman hunts Joker; in the movie, Joker hunts Batman.
Paradigmatic: The two Jokers also contain a paradigmatic difference between the two adaptations, this being the defining relationships of Harvey Dent and Harley Quinn. Not appearing in the 2008 film, Harley Quinn is a character that is as important to the Joker in the animated series as Batman. Harley was Joker's psychiatrist who is emotionally manipulated into his service, becoming something of a lapdog blindly loyal and in love to him. In the 2008 film, it's Harvey Dent who is manipulated by Joker into becoming the villainous Two-Face. The 1992 cartoon shows a lovesick woman exploited into blind service to the Joker, while the movie Joker's victim is a man who once held a position of power.
No comments:
Post a Comment